Tag: 1989

Berserk (Manga) Review

Berserk (Manga) Review

The Highest-Rated Manga of All Time

Berserk (ベルセルク) is the highest-rated manga of all time. And, it’s not even close. If we look at MyAnimeList, it has an average score of 9.47/10. The second-place manga is Jojo’s Part 7 with a 9.30. That might seem close, but it’s not. A difference of 0.17 is huge.

For comparison, let’s look at the highest-rated anime. Right now, it’s Frieren with a 9.17. But, that’s still airing so we can’t trust its rating. Many airing anime have reached the #1 spot before falling. The next two highest are FMA: Brotherhood with 9.09 and Steins;Gate with 9.07 — only a 0.02 difference.

Oh, and in case Berserk’s #1 ranking isn’t enough, it’s also the most popular manga on MyAnimeList. Ranking is how highly a manga is rated. Popularity is how many people have read it. So, more people have read Berserk than any other manga — even Attack on Titan and One Piece (the next two most popular).

Now, with all that said, I actually don’t think Berserk is the best manga I’ve read. But, in this review, I’m going to discuss each of the five major arcs and give my thoughts on them.

Black Swordsman Arc (Chapters 0-8)

Berserk Volume 1 manga cover art
Berserk Volume 1

The first arc of the series, the Black Swordsman arc, is also the shortest. However, it’s not the first chronologically. This is actually a look into the future, between the Golden Age and Conviction arcs. So, we get to see a glimpse of where the story’s going to be headed.

Since this arc is so short, not all that much happens in it. We’re introduced to Guts and Puck. Guts defeats two Apostles of the Godhand. And, we get the introduction of the five members of the Godhand — the main antagonists of the series.

Overall, this is a pretty strong start to the series. I like when we’re thrown right into the action from the start. But, that doesn’t mean it’s perfect. One issue I have with it is the mere existence of Puck. This might be blasphemy to other Berserk fans, but I don’t like Puck.

Also, I get that this is only the first few chapters. But, Guts isn’t exactly a very interesting character here. I saw someone claiming that he never develops throughout the series — and that’s simply not true. But, if you only read the beginning, I can see how you’d think he’s one-dimensional.

Golden Age Arc (Chapters 9-94)

Berserk Volume 5 manga cover art
Berserk Volume 5

The Golden Age arc is the second arc of the series and my personal favorite. This is the only arc I’d rate as a 10/10. It’s what I consider peak Berserk — which is kind of weird to say since it’s pretty different than the rest of the series.

This is the arc covering Guts’s origin story and the major events that made him who he is. From a young age, all Guts has known is the battlefield. And one day, he’s recruited into the Band of the Falcon by Griffith — a man who wants to create his own kingdom.

I think what makes this arc so great is all the characters within the Band of the Falcon and how they interact with each other. Also, it features a lot of large-scale battles between armies, which is cool. Oh, and Puck doesn’t exist in this arc, which I loved. But, the highlight of the arc comes at the end.

The golden age ends with an event known as the Eclipse. Without getting into major spoilers, everything changes on the day of the Eclipse. Guts, Griffith, and the Band of the Falcon will never be the same.

Conviction Arc (Chapters 95-176)

Berserk Volume 18 manga cover art
Berserk Volume 18

The Conviction arc is my second favorite arc of the series. It’s pretty much a longer version of the Black Swordsman arc, which therefore makes it better. But, it’s not as good as the Golden Age arc. Puck is back and the focus is no longer on the Band of the Falcon.

This arc is all about rescuing Casca and Guts’s determination to defeat Griffith. That’s cool. I like that. It also introduces some new main characters: Isidro, Farnese, and Serpico. But, I have mixed feelings about these additions. To me, they’re what starts bringing the series down.

Like Puck, Isidro is mostly a comedic relief character, which I don’t like in this series. And, I don’t know if I can explain why, but I don’t like Serpico either. He annoys me. But then, we have Farnese. When Farnese was introduced, I had very high hopes for her.

She’s originally an enemy of Guts and is hunting him down on behalf of the Holy See. She’s also a sadomasochist, which is awesome. But, neither of those things lasts beyond about the first half of this arc. She becomes an ally of guts, stops being kinky, and becomes a boring wimp.

Falcon of the Millennium Empire Arc (Chapters 177-307)

Berserk Volume 22 manga cover art
Berserk Volume 22

The Falcon of the Millennium Empire arc (or Millennium Falcon arc, for short) is the longest arc, so far. Fantasia might surpass it, but isn’t complete yet. Apparently, this is a popular arc. But, it’s actually my least favorite of the five that exist.

In this arc, Isidro, Farnese, and Serpico officially join Guts on his journey. And, Schierke and Ivalera join, as well. Schierke is a young witch and is currently my favorite of Guts’s companions. Ivalera is an elf and is there for comic relief like Puck and Isidro (so I don’t care for her).

This is really the arc where Farnese becomes boring. I mentioned Casca earlier, but she was a former Band of the Falcon member like Guts. And, back then, she was a very cool character. But now, her mind has reverted to that of a child and Farnese is her babysitter.

So, that’s not exactly what I like to see. But, what I did like to see is how Schierke shakes up the dynamic of the entire series by introducing magic. Unfortunately, that’s also counteracted by a lot of the monster horde fights in this arc being long and repetitive.

Fantasia Arc (Chapters 308-Present)

Berserk Volume 38 manga cover art
Berserk Volume 38

The Fantasia arc is the current arc — and should be completed eventually. But, it was delayed for quite a while after the death of Kentarou Miura in 2021. One of his close friends is working with the rest of Miura’s team to complete the manga.

Now, Fantasia isn’t my least favorite arc. But, it starts off with content I didn’t like very much. The beginning of this arc has a lot of the same drawn-out, repetitive monster horde fights that we got in the Millennium Falcon arc. I didn’t enjoy all the pirate and sea monster stuff.

However, the “second half” is better. Guts’s party makes its way to Elfhelm, the island home of the elves. And there, Casca’s memories are restored. Since I was a big fan of Casca in the Golden Age arc, I was glad to see her “return” in this arc.

Also, this arc is setting up for the major battle between Guts’s group and Griffith’s new kingdom. Until this arc, Griffith focused on consolidating his power and taking out his rivals. But now, he’s changing the entire world as we know it. And, it’s clear that he realizes he’ll need to fight Guts (again) at some point.

Final Thoughts

As a whole, I’m going to give Berserk a 9/10. If I averaged my scores for each arc, it would likely end up as an 8. But, that would be a bit misleading since the arcs don’t exist in a vacuum. I also have to take into consideration the overall story and character development.

I’ll probably revisit the Berserk manga when it finishes. That is if this blog still exists in 10+ years when that happens. But, considering I’m still going strong after over 6 years, that seems possible.

If you enjoyed this review, remember to share it with everyone you know. Also, follow me on your social media of choice so you don’t miss out on any future articles — links are in the footer.

Finally, I’d like to thank Roman and JasonHK for supporting DoubleSama.com at the Heika tier this month. To learn more about the perks of supporting this blog, check out DoubleSama.com/support.

Discord Community

Discuss anime, manga, and more with our members!

Join Server

Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga Review

Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga Review

Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga anime movie cover art
Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga

Planet of the Apes (and Psychics)

Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga, also called Garaga (ギャラガ), is a sci-fi anime movie from 1989. It was the worst, full-length, Japanese anime movie I found on MyAnimeList. There were worse movies, but they either weren’t full-length of were Korean.

So, of course, I decided we’d watch Garaga for August’s movie night in the DoubleSama Discord server. I was hoping that it would be so bad it was funny, like Garzey’s Wing. But, that wasn’t the case. Though, that could partly be because we watched it in Japanese, not the English dub.

Anyway, what makes Garaga bad is that it really doesn’t make much sense. While watching the movie, I thought I was following along with the plot just fine. But, after thinking back on the movie, I have no idea what was going on or why.

Jay using his weapon from the anime movie Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga
Jay using his weapon

The basic plot of Garaga is that a space ship crash lands on a planet called Garaga. And on this planet are at least two sentient races, the Umlangans and the Lars. The Umlangans are ape-like creatures and the Lars are psychics who look like humans. Well, at least, that’s what Lars are supposed to be.

As far as I remember, there’s only one psychic in the whole movie, Farla. The other Lars we see don’t ever exhibit psychic powers. I could be forgetting when they do. But, they’re functionally the same as humans other than Farla.

Anyway, the Umlangans and Lars are in a war over control of Garaga. And, because of course, humanity chose a side and got involved. The humans are on the side of the Umlangans fighting against the Lars. But, not because they want the Umlangans to win. They want the Lars to lose so that the humans can strip Garaga of its natural resources.

It Was the T-800 All Along

So far, nothing I’ve explained should be confusing. The very basic plot of the movie makes sense. It starts getting messy once we introduce all the various characters and their goals. There are quite a few characters in this movie. And each one seems to have their own motive you need to keep track of.

Though, don’t worry if you forget why a particular character is doing a particular thing. The majority of these character arcs don’t go anywhere and are never explained. For example, there’s Galliego (pictured below), one of the bad guys.

For some reason, he raises Kina to believe that Farla is a traitor to the Lars. But, then on his deathbed, he admits he was lying about that the whole time. We never get an explanation for why he lied about Farla. Though, I assume the answer is because he wouldn’t be a villain otherwise.

Galliego from the anime movie Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga
Galliego

There are also multiple human factions running around Garaga doing their own things. Some want to assassinate the human general. Others want to deliver the general’s daughter to him in a warzone, for some reason. And then there’s Jay, whose mysterious background we never learn. He’s the protagonist, by the way.

So, who’s the actual villain of the movie? Is it Galliego, the “evil” Lars? Is it Farla, the traitor? Kromen Gornue, general of the Umlangans? What about General Yun, leader of the human forces? Well, it’s none of them. It’s a guy named Alf Dolf.

Alf Dolf, which is a great name, is a cyborg who works directly under General Yun. And like any good cyborg, his goal is to eradicate all the organic life forms in the galaxy. Why are the humans, Umlangans, and Lars fighting a war against each other? Alf Dolf manipulated them all.

I Guess the Apes Won?

The very end of the movie also doesn’t make much sense. Jay goes off on his next adventure without explaining things. But, that’s par for the course when it comes to Jay, at this point. What doesn’t make sense is how the war over Garaga gets resolved.

Once Jay defeats Alf Dolf, everything should be fine. He was the cause of the war. Alf Dolf was brainwashing General Yun into committing atrocities on Garaga. And one of those atrocities was turning the Umlangans into super soldiers. Before the humans arrived, the Umlangans were a peaceful race.

So, without Alf Dolf in the picture, General Yun has no reason to turn the Umlangans into soldiers. And, the humans pull out from Garaga, which resolves the war with the Lars. So, yes, everything is fine once Alf Dolf is gone. But, there’s still one confusing detail left.

Farla from the anime movie Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga
Farla

You see, the humans aren’t the only ones who leave Garaga. All the Lars also leave Garaga. And I have no idea why. Wasn’t the whole point of the Lars (Farla) fighting to protect Garaga from being exploited? The Lars are also a native race of Garaga. So, why are they leaving?

My only guess is that due to the experiments the humans performed, the Umlangans became too smart. Maybe the issue is that there can only be one sentient species at the top. Before, that would have been the Lars. But now, the Umlangans have advanced technology and culture, as well.

That still doesn’t exactly make sense, though. I mean, without the humans in the picture, why would the Umlangans and Lars fight? Ideology? Maybe. But, wouldn’t the same thing happen if the Lars go to Earth with the humans? Though, to be fair, we don’t know where the Lars are going.

Garaga: 5/10

Hyper-Psychic Geo Garaga isn’t a good movie. But, it’s also not actually that bad. Yes, when you think about the movie after the fact, it doesn’t make much sense. However, while watching the movie, I thought it was pretty average for an old anime. So, it gets a 5/10 from me.

Some people would rate Garaga lower just for being old. I’m not going to hold that against it. Also, the basic plot is pretty good, even if it’s not executed well. The biggest problem with the movie comes from all the loose ends. But, I feel like a lot of older anime movies have the same issue.

I mean, look at Akira, a good anime from a year before Garaga. It only covers the first half of the story and then ends. So, plot points being left unfinished or rushed isn’t exactly unique to bad anime from that time.

Anyway, if you enjoyed this review, remember to share it with everyone you know. Also, follow me on your social media of choice so you don’t miss out on any future articles — links are in the footer.

Finally, I’d like to thank Roman and JasonHK for supporting DoubleSama.com at the Heika tier this month. To learn more about becoming a supporter of this blog, check out Patreon.com/DoubleSama.

Discord Community

Discuss anime, manga, and more with our members!

Join Server

Kiki’s Delivery Service

Kiki’s Delivery Service

Kiki's Delivery Service anime movie cover art
Kiki’s Delivery Service Cover Art

Overview

Kiki’s Delivery Service is a coming-of-age story that doesn’t try to disguise the fact that it’s a coming-of-age story. Right at the start we’re introduced to the protagonist, Kiki, as she decides to leave home and go off on her own at the age of 13 (as is customary for her family).

This may sound somewhat extreme, and if you actually think about it for a bit, you’ll realize it is, but Kiki is a witch, not some random girl without the ability to fly, so I’m sure she’ll be just fine. Oh, and she has a talking cat with her too, so it’s not like she’s alone.

When witches come of age, it’s customary for them to leave their homes and find somewhere new in the world to live and set up shop for a year of “training.” I’m not really sure what part of this is training though, since these young girls don’t work under mentors or anything.

Kiki, for reasons I’ll explain later, decides to create a flying delivery service (hence the title of the movie) in a large town by the ocean. It appears to be somewhere on the coast of Italy, so not a bad place to settle down if you ask me.

It’s also hinted at that there should only be one witch per town, or at least only one witch in training per town, but that’s not something that’s ever explicitly told to the viewer.

Over the course of the film, Kiki’s delivery service basically devolves into Kiki’s odd-jobs service, as she tends to do more than simply deliver packages. She helps bake cakes, changes light bulbs, poses for paintings, and sometimes delivers things in between.

During the low point in the story, our young protagonist temporarily loses her witch abilities. This means she can no longer fly on her broom and Jiji, her pet talking cat, turns back into a regular cat. Since there aren’t any real antagonists in the story, this was a fairly predictable development, as was how it was resolved.

The boy Kiki potentially likes, Tombo, gets carried away by a runaway airship, and so Kiki has to muster all her heart and magic to rescue him. I know this is a children’s movie, but when the airship crashes into the clock tower and collapses onto the town, not many of the characters seem to comprehend how big of a disaster that is.

Now, when first starting this movie you may feel like it’s going to be some grand, magical adventure, but in reality, it quickly turns into little more than a slice of life story about Kiki living in a bakery and working odd jobs, as I previously mentioned. There’s not much real magic or wonder to be found, but I’ll talk more about that in the conclusion.

Kiki being given candy from the anime movie Kiki's Delivery Service
Kiki

Characters

Kiki, our 13-year-old protagonist’s only real defining trait is that she’s a witch. She has other traits such as the fact that she wears only black (I know, her bow and shoes are red, but ignore that), and that she can fly on a broom, but those are simply sub-traits she has due to being a witch.

The reason she started a delivery service is because flying is the only thing she’s good at. Early on in the movie we meet another witch about the same age as Kiki who’s working as a psychic, and Kiki’s mother is always shown making potions, hinting at two other possible jobs for witches.

Overall I found her to be a fairly bland character. She’s kind of tsundere, but not quite in the way we see tsundere today, and she doesn’t necessarily have any special quirk which makes her stand out.

I think the reason I feel that Kiki is such a bland character is simply because of all the newer anime I’ve watched. In today’s anime landscape, every character needs to be jam-packed with tropes and quirks which make them unique, so much so that we’ve started to see that as the norm.

Jiji is Kiki’s pet cat who has the ability to speak. Like many animals with the ability to speak in children’s movies, Jiji is also shown to have human-like intelligence. Now, that may seem like an obvious detail not worth mentioning, but it does actually come into play later in the movie.

When Kiki loses her magic, Jiji not only loses his ability to speak but also appears to revert back to the standard intelligence level of a cat. He no longer stays by Kiki’s side but rather does cat things like drink milk out of a bowl and chase after a female cat.

One thing about this part of the movie which I found interesting was that after Kiki regains her magic and can fly on a broom again, Jiji doesn’t appear to ever regain his speech and intelligence. He’s still shown to be meowing instead of speaking even in the epilogue, although now he also has a kitten.

Maybe Jiji could never actually speak all along and he was just a metaphor for Kiki’s lack of friends. Once she starts to gain friends she doesn’t need a talking cat for companionship anymore after all.

Some of the less important supporting characters are Osono, Tombo, and Ursula.

Osono is a baker who lives with her husband (also a baker) in the town Kiki settles down in. She takes Kiki in after Kiki helps her return a pacifier to a customer who left it in the bakery and becomes a foster parent for Kiki. Her husband is basically a caveman; I think he had one word of dialogue.

Tombo is Kiki’s potential love interest, but their relationship is more of a friendship than anything else. He’s the first friend Kiki makes who’s her own age since leaving her hometown to start her journey (although they aren’t exactly friends at first). Flying is one of Tombo’s dreams.

Ursula is a painter who lives in the forest outside of town. She’s a few years older than Kiki, and they met when a package Kiki was delivering was dropped outside of Ursula’s house. Overall, Ursula wasn’t that important to the story, but she was a somewhat recurring character.

Kiki and Jiji flying with seagulls from the anime movie Kiki's Delivery Service
Kiki and Jiji

Conclusion

If you’ve seen my reviews of movies before, especially ones considered “childhood classics” for many people, my rating shouldn’t come as much of a surprise. Kiki’s Delivery Service is a 5/10.

There were parts of the movie which I liked a lot, such as when Kiki borrowed some random guy’s broom and then stood in the middle of the street trying to get it to fly while the crowd stared at her, dumbfounded during the climax. Or, when later on that same guy was telling everyone that the broom she used was his.

However, most of the movie was extremely slow without much actually happening. Kiki would go make a delivery, something would “go wrong” (usually not that wrong), and then she’d end up doing some sort of odd job. I guess I just wanted there to be a little more adventure.

Unfortunately, a problem arose when rating this movie. I was torn between giving it a 5 or a 6, but because I was so torn I figured that probably meant it deserved the 5. That said, if I had given it a 6, that would mean it’s on the same level as Ordinal Scale, or Akira, which it isn’t.

And I’m not going to bump those movies up to 7s just because of Kiki’s Delivery Service, so that means it must be a 5. But, when looking through posts to choose which ones I’ll be featuring this month, I noticed I rated Eureka Seven as a 5 as well even though that too is better than Kiki’s.

What I’m trying to get at here is that I may rewatch some of the series I watched and rated a while back and do some updated reviews. Eureka Seven is first on my list for this, but who knows when I’ll actually get around to doing that considering how much I still have to watch.

Anyway, let me know whether or not you agree with my review of Kiki’s Delivery Service down in the comments below. I look forward to hearing how I’m wrong and that Kiki’s is the perfect movie, though I doubt your words will change my mind.

Also, if you enjoyed this review, consider scrolling down a bit and clicking the little heart under this post. Likes let me know what kind of content is the most popular and can influence what I write about in the future.

If you’d like to be notified whenever a new post goes live on the site, subscribe to my blog via email (in the sidebar on PC and down below this post on mobile devices), or follow me on Twitter @DoubleSama.